Dumbing Down Tumblr

Style b­logging is a beautiful if somewhat chaotic medley of fashion, design, and the every-day-girl. As with a lot social media tools like Facebook and Twitter, anything and everything goes. It’s a candid mish-mash of individual perspectives, formed to create a sort of digital look book of all things stylish. Like moths fluttering towards bright lights bulbs, so too are the fashion-savvy towards the blogosphere. Blogs show case the lives and loves of normal girls, and if the success of tabloids and reality TV is anything to go by, we can’t get enough of the everyday Jane.

But therein lies the rub. What happens when the everyday girl is just as beautiful, just as thin, just as well dressed as the fashion models we see in magazines? Has the every-day become the glossy world of picture perfectionism? We crave diversity, but are we really rising to the challenge with the tools that let us do so?

Source: Tumblr

Let me illustrate. There is a girl I follow on Tumblr with thousands of fans. At just a mere 17-years of age, she has reached what is known as internet fame. Everyday she uploads or reblogs a beautiful mixture of images she finds from all corners of the web, creating a fashion-lover’s archive of inspiration for the self-confessed clothes horse. She is adored not just for her treasure trove of pictures, but also for own personal style. Self-portraits of thin, tanned legs reclining in a computer chair, a messy head of long blonde hair and a perfect pout receive hundreds of notes, likes a reblogs. She’s internet famous, and all she has to do is click her mouse.

“How did u get soooo skinny?!” One follower asks.

“can we plz get a rundown of what you eat each day?” Asks another.

The reaction to these images, whether they’re of the bloggers themselves or of catwalk models they admire, is uncannily similar to the way we react to the headlines that blazen the covers of magazines. We want to know what the other person does to look and feel good. What’s their secret? How can I be like them? How do I compare?

The girls of Tumblr are undoubtedly gorgeous, a community of style bloggers, amateur fashion designers and enthusiasts, writers and makeup artists alike. They love what they do, and best of all, they’re just like us. However, just like the perfectly choreographed images they post, web cam shots become DIY fashion shoots with real designer labels and some serious effort involved.

Fashion and beauty have always been about creating magical worlds, with control over these fantasies commanded from the top down. The Internet has given fashion and beauty lovers a place to openly share and create their own worlds, and take a little bit more control over what the media hands to us. The thing is, sometimes the pages of Tumblr aren’t that far away from the sartorial jungles of high-fashion magazines. The everyday fashion blogger and her Tumblr posts start to look more and more like the unattainable world we see inside the glossy covers of our favorite reads. Sometimes, it’s a little hard not to compare ourselves, especially when the girls responsible might even be people we know.

Social media tools like Tumblr are great for getting the creative juices flowing yes, but if something you’re viewing at is making you constantly look at yourself and how you compare, where’s the fun in that? And that’s what blogging should be all about – fun! Creativity! Expressing yourself and sharing your passion. Tumblr is just another form of media, and just as with magazines, television, movies and other images you see, it’s important to think about how blog content is created. Is it opening up your world to a variety of looks, styles and tastes? Or is it just reflecting the same old, same old?

9 comments
  1. natasiarose says: October 19, 20113:07 pm

    Great post! Personally, I like my blog to be more about fun. But it’s a choice between putting effort into your words or putting effort into your appearance (online)

    Sometimes I think I should just learn to use photoshop and turn myself into a flawless beauty and see how many more hits I get!

  2. [...] you like my post about Tumblr and street style? I’m not the only one who’s skeptical of street fashion [...]

  3. [...] • What happens when style bloggers start resembling magazine cover girls? [...]

  4. [...] a blog then read it. ? A Modern Mellow Yellow Wedding ? ReStyle a comfy sweatshirt DIY ? Dumbing down tumblr – when fashion & style bloggers are just as pretty & thin as fashion models ? [...]

  5. Ana says: November 19, 20119:29 am

    Good article.

    I think the responsibility lies in us as readers and not in us/them as bloggers – we are the ones asking those questions, we are the ones creating a celebrity-like buzz around them.
    Bloggers aren’t to… blame, for lack of a better word, for fitting a socially-accepted-standard-of-beauty.
    Those who fit are just people, just as those who don’t fit are.

  6. LINK-LADEN | Insomnias says: November 20, 20115:55 pm

    [...] The girls of Tumblr: beginning to look like they’re right off the catwalk? [...]

  7. Allison Jones Design says: November 20, 201110:43 pm

    Nice blog post! Blogs certainly have the capacity to open up ones world to different styles, fashions and the beauty of it is each blog is delivered through the voice of each individual blogger! There are so many diamonds out there! Love YOUR creative voice on this platform.

  8. Girls Are Made From Pepsi » Tumblr Watch says: December 9, 201111:10 am

    [...] made a post earlier about a few issues I had with the platform, but there’s also a lot of things about Tumblr that [...]

  9. [...] It wasn’t until probably two years ago when I started studying journalism that I learnt of the media’s power and the manufacturing of desire. I learnt that I’d been duped. I was but a mere pawn in a system that is designed to make money from making girls feel bad about themselves. I’m proud of the fact that I don’t feel that a bottle of perfume will enhance my quality of life, or that the key to success lies in a pair of shoes, a dress, or an expensive hair cut. I trip up from time to time, as my credit card debt will testify. My media consumption’s changed not just with age (and a brief graduation from Dolly and Girlfriend to Cosmopolitan and Cleo), but also with the times. Tumblr and fashion blogs over costly magazines is now the riguer du jour for the conscientious female. Of course, these can also be harmful too, as I’ve written about previously. [...]

Submit comment